My HONEST Quince Review: What I Liked & What to Avoid [2024]

The author of this Quince Clothing Review, a young woman wearing black pants and a dark blue jacket, stands in a rainy, hilly, green countryside landscape beneath an overcast sky.

By

‎ ‎‎‎| Last updated: December 19th, 2023

TL;DR: Quince first caught my attention with its quality clothing at affordable prices. I learned that, while I found the clothes comfortable and stylish, the quality fell short a few times. These are the key takeaways from my Quince review:

  • The first two words that come to mind when I think about Quince clothing pieces are: soft & thin.
  • The quality of Quince items reflects the price you pay for them.
  • Pieces are versatile, and you can dress them up or down.
  • Quince’s sizing guide is mostly spot-on.
  • Quince is on the path to comprehensive sustainable practices.

Quince has made a name for itself by offering luxury-inspired pieces at a fraction of the price. But is the quality there or is it too good to be true?

As an avid traveler, I took it upon myself to truly test out Quince. I wore multiple outfits during a 3-week trip abroad to assess comfort, versatility, and durability.

Like many mid-to-lower-cost fashion brands, Quince offers clothing that often mimics higher-end brands. 

This is why I especially wanted to test pieces that were replicas from higher-end brands like the Quince Neoprene Backpack [similar to the Dagne Dover Dakota Backpack] and the Lightweight Down Puffer Jacket [Similar to the Patagonia Nano Puff]. I was curious to see how the Quince versions would compare.

Overall, I tested 10 pieces of clothing along with a popular Quince backpack. Traveling with these items meant I could wear them quite a few times within a relatively short time. I quickly got a feel for what worked and what didn’t.

If you’ve been eyeing Quince yourself, stick around for my detailed and honest Quince review. I’ll cut through the hype and share which exact items passed my quality test with flying colors–and which ones fell short. 

Details

My favorite Quince dress
Tencel Jersey Fit & Flare Dress – Comfortable, lightweight, and versatile.

Quality
The quality matches the price, and there’s a 365-day return policy if something doesn’t work out.

Pros

  • Quince offers very trendy, yet timeless pieces.
  • Very affordable.
  • They use silky, smooth fabrics that are super soft and comfortable.
  • Quince’s sizing guide was helpful and mostly accurate.
  • Quince claims that 70% of products are made of recycled materials and they have safe, equitable factories.

Cons

  • Quality control is inconsistent.
  • Only sizes small to extra large are available.
  • Questionable durability.
  • They lack certifications to prove their sustainability efforts.

What is Quince?

A close-up of a grey tank top on a clothing hanger, with a printed label reading "Quince" visible inside.

Quince describes itself as a brand that offers high-quality essentials at an affordable price. 

As I mentioned above, I was initially intrigued by the Quince brand because of their low prices and style of clothing. Their pieces reminded me of other, more expensive brands, but with the promise of fairer prices.

Quince boasts that they use high-quality materials like organic linen, organic cotton, Italian leather, alpaca wool, and more. I also heard good things about their silk and merino wool products. 

In addition to these materials, Quince uses eco-friendly dyes whenever possible. 

Aside from clothing, Quince sells all kinds of items in categories such as Home, Baby & Kids, and Luggage. Their website offers plenty of variety, from leather goods like leather jackets to home goods like sheet sets.

Quince also claims that they have made-to-order items, which makes it seem like they’re more focused on sustainability than fast fashion. 

However, other than mentioning made-to-order items on their shipping page, I haven’t seen any direct examples of truly made-to-order items on their website.

Quince Review: My Experience With Quince’s Clothing

An older man in a sea-green shirt stands next to a young woman in black pants and a black jacket on a cliff overlooking a turquoise ocean, with an arch-shaped coastal rock formation.
Wearing the Ponte Pants and Merino Wool Sweater while exploring the Jurassic Coast with my dad in the UK.

The 10 pieces of clothing I tested were a mix of tops, bottoms, and dresses. I also tried one of their accessories–a backpack. 

Aside from a quirk or two, I’d say most pieces worked out great as everyday clothing.

However, not all of them were ideal for travel–mainly due to easy-to-wrinkle material and restrictive washing instructions (like needing to put them in the hand/gentle wash or letting them air dry). 

Multiple pieces fell in the middle, but there were outliers. In this mix were pieces like the Merino wool sweater (which was more or less a loss) versus the jersey fit & flare dress (which is my latest go-to piece in my closet). 

It’s difficult to pin down my experience with Quince into a simple yay or nay. I invite you to read through my experience with each piece to better understand what may work for you.

Tencel Jersey Fit & Flare Dress

A young woman wearing a brown Tencel Jersey Fit & Flare Dress stands facing the camera with her hands in her pockets in an interior setting with a map of California on the wall behind her.
A young woman wearing a brown Tencel Jersey Fit & Flare Dress stands to the side, smiling over her shoulder in an interior setting with a map of California on the wall behind her.

One of my new favorite dresses–the Jersey Fit & Flare Dress! This one has a nice bounce to it, is super comfortable and stylish, and fits well.

I tested out the Tencel Jersey Fit & Flare Dress in brown, size small. 

Rating: 10/10

When it comes to Quince dresses, I absolutely love the Jersey Fit & Flare Dress. The jersey material makes the dress very comfortable while still being lightweight. 

The tank top style lets you wear the dress with a regular-style bra. I also like the length, which is versatile for several different occasions. 

The great thing about this dress is that you can dress it up or down; it works for going out with friends or touring a city while traveling. 

Plus, it has pockets! Anyone familiar with wearing dresses knows that having pockets is a reason to rejoice.

Lastly, this dress washed well without issues (unlike some of the other Quince pieces I tried). 

Tencel Rib Knit Sleeveless Dress

A young woman wearing a grey Tencel Rib Knit Sleeveless Dress stands looking down in an interior setting with a map of California on the wall behind her.
A young woman wearing a grey Tencel Rib Knit Sleeveless Dress stands to the side, smiling over her shoulder in an interior setting with a map of California on the wall behind her.

You can see how the lining doesn’t match up on the side in the right-hand photo. I wasn’t a fan of the lining moving around so much and hardly ever being lined up where I wanted it to be.

I tested out the Tencel Rib Knit Sleeveless Dress in dark olive, size small.  

Rating: 4/10

I love the color and ultra-soft fabric of this Tencel Rib Knit Sleeveless Dress. But while it’s incredibly soft, it’s also a bit thin. 

While wearing this dress, I noticed the lining bunching easily. 

After examining why this might be, I found the inner lining wasn’t closely sewn into the rest of the fabric, meaning the layers separated easily and bunched up. Because of this, I didn’t end up wearing it much. 

This dress is one of a few examples of quality control issues with some of my Quince pieces.

Cotton Fisherman Crew Sweater

A young woman wearing a white sweater and a blue plaid skirt stands smiles at the camera in front of a hardwood interior.
A young woman wearing a white sweater and a blue plaid skirt stands looking down at her feet in a hardwood interior.

Although the first sweater I received had a hole in it, once I got it replaced, I generally liked wearing this sweater. It’s not anything to write home about–the design is a little on the boxy side and it’s not that cozy–but it’s a nice basic to have in my closet.

I tested out the Cotton Fisherman Crew Sweater in ivory, size small. 

Rating: 6/10

I didn’t have a great first impression of the Cotton Fisherman Crew Sweater because it arrived with a small hole in the front. After an e-mail to customer service, a replacement quickly arrived in the mail. 

Still, I find the quality falls a bit short. As far as cotton sweaters go, I don’t find this one particularly breathable. 

I’m always down for a sweater with a relaxed fit, but this particular choice has a roomier fit than expected, which makes it a bit too boxy for my liking. 

I still wear it somewhat often, but I wouldn’t say it’s a favorite sweater. 

Ultra-Soft High-Rise Legging – 28″ Inseam

A young woman wearing grey Ultra-Soft High-Rise Leggings and a yellow shirt stands facing the camera, lifting her shirt to touch her waistband in an interior setting with a map of California on the wall behind her.
A young woman wearing grey Ultra-Soft High-Rise Leggings and a yellow shirt stands to the side, looking down in an interior setting with a map of California on the wall behind her.

These leggings are on the thinner side but their silky soft material made them an immediate favorite for long travel days.

I tested out the Ultra-Soft High-Rise Legging in heather charcoal, size small. 

Rating: 8/10

These Ultra-Soft High-Rise Leggings are true to their name–they’re cloud-like soft, and fit well. 

I brought them on my recent UK trip, and they made excellent travel day pants. I especially loved wearing them on the long flight to and from the UK because of how cozy they are. 

The only downside to these leggings is that they’re a little thin. Ultimately, the thinness isn’t too bad (they weren’t see-through or anything), and I definitely plan to wear these more. 

Ultra-Stretch Ponte Straight Leg Pant – Tall

A young woman in black pants and a white tank top stands in front of the Tower of London on a sunny day.
An older man in a white t-shirt stands next to a young woman in black pants and a white tank top in front of the London Bridge on a sunny day.

I wore my Ponte Pants most days of my UK trip since they were so comfortable and versatile. I just wish I had gone with my usual pant size (medium) instead of going off the sizing chart for this one.

I tested out the Ultra-Stretch Ponte Straight Leg Pant in navy, size small (and tall). 

Rating: 7/10

The Ultra-Stretch Ponte Straight Leg Pant is an excellent choice for everyday wear while traveling. They’re versatile enough to work well as a pair of work pants, too. 

I like that these have an almost legging-like feel without the legging look. 

In terms of fit, the pants are a bit tighter than I usually like. But that was my bad for ordering a size small instead of medium (my usual pant size). 

I ordered a small because I was going off the size measurements on their site and thought they’d be pretty stretchy. They aren’t thaat stretchy, though, and they’d be a more comfortable fit overall if I had sized up.  

These pants have two main cons to note. 

First, no pockets. While that does add to the sleek, form-fitting look, I always love pockets for functionality.

The second con comes with quality control. I’ve noticed after a few wears now that the stitching is beginning to come apart slightly on the sides. There are no holes yet, but it makes me think these pants might not last that long. 

Australian Merino Wool V-Neck Sweater

A young woman in black pants and a black jacket stands on a cliff overlooking a turquoise ocean, with an arch-shaped coastal rock formation.
A young woman wearing a dark grey V-Neck Sweater smiles at the camera and holds up an empty beer glass inside of a pub.

I ended up wearing this sweater a lot on my trip because it was the only one I brought, but I just thought it was okay. It was stylish and did its job of keeping me warm but it was a little too scratchy for my taste.

I tried the discontinued Australian Merino Wool Sweater in black, size small. This is now the closest option.

Rating: 6/10

Wearing this Australian Merino Wool V-Neck Sweater was fine–until it needed a wash. 

This piece completely shrunk after a wash on the gentle cycle. That may be on me for not researching the proper washing technique (spoiler alert: hand wash only). 

But when I say this sweater shrunk, it shrunk. It’s at the point where it’d probably only fit a child. Wearing it is out of the question now…

Maybe that’s okay, though, since I found the wool to be a bit scratchy and not as soft other wool sweaters I own. 

Lightweight Down Puffer Jacket

A young woman in a black Lightweight Down Puffer Jacket stands on the deck of a boat in front of the London Bridge on a overcast day.
An older man in a black jacket poses next to a young woman in a black Lightweight Down Puffer Jacket from the deck of a boat in front of the London Bridge on a overcast day.

Another piece that I wore almost every day for three weeks, this one was a decent knock-off of the Patagonia Nano Puff, but was hard to wash and didn’t always keep me quite as warm as I wanted.

I tested out this Lightweight Down Puffer Jacket in black, size small.

Rating: 8/10

I chose to try this Lightweight Down Puffer Jacket because it’s a similar style to the Patagonia Nano Puff. While the jacket looks similar from afar, there’s a noticeable difference in warmth. 

I wasn’t always quite warm enough in this on chilly nights in the UK. With that said, the jacket has worked great for day-to-day wear since I arrived back in warmer California.

The true disappointment I faced with this jacket came after washing it on a gentle cycle. There was a noticeable decrease in puffiness, and the interior feathers began coming out.

This could be a mistake on my end for not hand washing, but it also concerns me when considering quality control.

Mongolian Cashmere Tee

A young woman wearing black pants and a yellow Mongolian Cashmere Tee poses next to a sign reading "Abbey Road" in front of a brick wall.
A young woman wearing black pants and a yellow Mongolian Cashmere Tee poses with one leg kicked up next to a red telephone booth.

I love the color and softness of this shirt and I’ve worn it a bunch now. The only downside is how thin it is, but that also means it’s a nice lightweight basic.

I tested out this Mongolian Cashmere Tee in spicy mustard, size small. 

Rating: 9/10

I love this Mongolian Cashmere Tee!

The cashmere is buttery, soft, and very lightweight. The only downside is that it’s a bit thin, meaning more see-through than I prefer. Choosing one of the darker colors may help this issue since I chose a pretty light color.

Then again, sometimes it’s nice to have cashmere t-shirts on the thin side because the material is so warm by nature.    

Still, the fit is great, and I love my chosen mustard color. 

Stretch Silk Short Sleeve Notch Collar Blouse

A young woman wearing a white Stretch Silk Short Sleeve Notch Collar Blouse stands, not smiling, in an interior setting with a map of California on the wall behind her.
A young woman wearing a white Stretch Silk Short Sleeve Notch Collar Blouse stands facing the camera, smiling, in an interior setting with a map of California on the wall behind her.

I wanted to like this silk shirt more, but it wrinkles SO easily. You basically have to iron or steam it every time you want to wear it again, which is a bit too much maintenance for me.

I tested out this Stretch Silk Short Sleeve Notch Collar Blouse in ivory, size small. 

Rating: 6/10

I was drawn to this Stretch Silk Short Sleeve Notch Collar Blouse because I loved the sound of a washable silk blouse.

While I enjoy wearing this shirt since it’s a different style and cut than I normally wear, it falls short in several ways.

First off, it’s very thin and, therefore, see-through. This may not be as big of an issue with the different color options like black and navy. But with the white option, I always have to wear it with an undershirt.

Additionally, this shirt wrinkles super easily. The first wear was fine, but I only wore it once on my three-week trip because I didn’t have the time or resources to steam it before starting each day.

You’d probably expect that from a material like washable silk, but it’s something to consider. 

Silk Slip Dress

A young woman wearing a dark blue Silk Slip Dress stands looking over her right shoulder in an interior setting with a map of California on the wall behind her.
A young woman wearing a dark blue Silk Slip Dress smiles and leans forward with her hands on her knees in an interior setting with a map of California on the wall behind her.

I like this dress a lot–classy, simple, yet timeless. I also like that the top part isn’t too revealing when you bend over, a rarity with this type of cut.

I tested out this Silk Slip Dress in navy, size small. 

Rating: 8/10

This Silk Slip dress is available in over nine colors, and I was glad I chose a dark one. 

The dress is very thin and wrinkles easily, like the other washable silk piece I tried. 

All that said, I really like the style and cut of this dress. There’s something elegant yet simple about it. I wear it for date nights or throw a sweater over the top to make a silk skirt out of the bottom half of the dress.

All-Day Neoprene Backpack

A young woman wearing a brown Neoprene Backpack, grey Ultra-Soft High-Rise Leggings and a yellow shirt stands to the side looking over her shoulder at the camera in an interior setting.
A young woman wearing a brown Neoprene Backpack, grey Ultra-Soft High-Rise Leggings and a yellow shirt stands with her back to the camera in an interior setting.

The Neoprene backpack is a very solid and stylish backpack, the only downside is its lack of padding.

I tested out this All-Day Neoprene Backpack in Mocha. 

Rating: 8/10

I was interested in the All-Day Neoprene Backpack because it reminded me of the Dagne Dover Neoprene Backpack but at half the price. 

I’m happy to report I liked this backpack even more than I expected. 

This is a great backpack to use as a personal item for flying or traveling in general. The bag has a built-in luggage strap on the back, allowing you to slide it over suitcase handles. I also like the velcro tablet pocket inside, the overall bag capacity, and the soft outer material.

There are just two downsides I’ve noticed about this backpack… 

First off, the straps don’t have much padding. After a long day of carrying this around exploring, the straps wore on my shoulders a bit. If there’s anything I could change, I’d add more padding for comfort.   

Additionally, the backpack’s water bottle holders are way too small. The sleeves barely fit a plastic water bottle you’d buy at the airport, let alone my standard-size 22-oz reusable water bottle.

It makes me think the pockets are more for style than functionality. 

Quince Sizing Tips & Fit

A young woman wearing black pants and a dark blue jacket walks down a road with her back to the camera in a rainy, hilly, green countryside landscape beneath an overcast sky.
The Ponte Pants ended up being my favorite everyday pants on my UK trip.

I typically prefer brands that offer sizing based on the numerical system, as I find it tends to be more specific than small, medium, and large. 

Regardless, I found the sizing guide on the website to be useful and correct (for the most part).

Quality Control

A woman wearing a white sweater seen from the shoulders down, pointing to a small hole in the sweater's chest.
The quality control for some Quince pieces was lacking, as demonstrated by this hole in the first Fisherman’s Crew Sweater I received.

Although Quince brands itself as a place to find good quality at affordable prices, I found the quality control to be lacking with a few pieces. 

Whether it was the lining that wasn’t attached well or the feathers that came out of the puffer jacket, I worry whether these pieces will last long term. 

Quince Return & Exchange Policy

A young woman wearing black pants and a dark blue jacket, stands in front of Stonehenge in a rainy, hilly, green countryside landscape beneath an overcast sky.
Wearing my Quince Ponte Pants at Stonehenge.

The timeline allotted for Quince returns is pretty impressive. Items can be returned up to 365 days from the purchase date–provided the items are unworn and in their original packaging. 

Any made-to-order items have a $35 restocking fee. 

Shipping is free and takes about 6-9 business days to arrive. You have the option to pay for expedited shipping if you wish. 

Currently, Quince only ships in the United States. Check their Shipping & Returns page for the most up-to-date information. 

Quince Discounts & Coupons

If you’re looking for a Quince discount code or sale, your best bet is to check during the major holidays that often bring sales, like Black Friday or Memorial Day. 

Where to Buy Quince Clothing

As Quince is a direct-to-consumer clothing brand, the only place you can buy Quince clothing is on their website.

FAQs About Quince Clothing

A young woman wearing leggings and a black Lightweight Down Puffer Jacket sits on a bench under a tree in a countryside landscape on a sunny day.
The puffer jacket has become a staple in my wardrobe since getting back from my trip. It works better in California than it did in the colder climate of the UK.

Is Quince legit?

Yes, Quince is legit. Many customers, myself included, have been quite happy with the products they’ve received from Quince.  

Is Quince real silk?

Yes! Quince offers 90% to 100% real silk products. 

Is Quince really high quality?

Yes and no. Quince markets itself as a brand that offers quality materials at better prices than other brands. However, from my experience, the quality faltered with at least a handful of pieces. 

Why is Quince cheap?

Quince explains that prices remain low because the middleman is cut out. Quince products are sourced directly from manufacturers and offered to customers. This practice is part of the direct-to-consumer model.

Is Quince a Chinese company?

While Quince is headquartered in San Francisco, California, they use more than 50 manufacturers from all over the globe to make their products. Some of these manufacturers are in China

Is Quince an ethical company?

When asked about sustainable practices beyond the information available on their website, Quince said:

“Our supply chain is socially and environmentally responsible, with 70% of our products being made from renewable materials, and 100% of the factories we work with are certified by third-party auditors to ensure safe and equitable working conditions.”

Additionally, Quince is working towards eliminating non-recycled plastics from their packaging. They promise to have all packaging 100% compostable by the end of 2023. 

You may find yourself sacrificing quality for the low prices. While Quince is not technically fast fashion, it kind of defeats the purpose if clothes don’t last long and must be replaced.

Conclusion: So, is Quince’s Clothing Worth it?

A young woman in black pants and a dark blue jacket stands on a stone balcony in front of a view of rolling countryside hills and an overcast sky.
I have a lot of photos of me in my Ponte Pants because they were so dang comfortable and versatile.

Based on my overall experience with the brand and clothing pieces I tried, I’d give Quince a 7/10 rating overall. 

Quince clothing is worth it–as long as you keep your expectations at the same level as the price. 

Higher quality, fully sustainable, and actual made-to-order items are out there. But if you want to try something a bit more accessible, check out Quince.


ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Mimi McFadden Headshot

Mimi McFadden
Founder & Editor-In-Chief

Mimi McFadden grew up in Santa Cruz, California, and founded The Atlas Heart in 2013. Mimi has always been into fashion to some extent, but really started paying attention to it more at the age of 28 when she no longer lived out of a backpack as a full-time traveler. Once she started owning her personal style (and had an actual closet), she focused on finding the perfect balance of comfort and versatility for her wardrobe. As one of the main clothing testers at The Atlas Heart, she is always on the lookout for fun new clothing brands to try out that can add style and comfort to her travels around California, especially those that focus on sustainability.

Monroe Dziersk Profile Pic

Monroe Dziersk

Monroe Dziersk is a twenty-something American who has lived in the USA, Italy, and Czechia. A self-proclaimed Europhile, she has a passion for international education, traveling, and becoming a global citizen, having visited more than twenty countries. You can often find her accompanied by a good book and her calico cat.


Shopping for more clothes? Check out our honest reviews on other brands below!

Quince Review Pin

Pin this image for future reference

Hi, I'm Mimi! I'm an outdoorsy Californian who has spent over 28 years immersed in the incredible natural beauty that California has to offer. My goal is to inspire others to get out and find their next adventure in California. Whether it’s escaping to an alpine lake in the Sierras, finding peace among the giant redwoods, or road tripping down the PCH, there’s always more to explore in this beautiful state.

LEARN MORE NORTHERN CALIFORNIA CENTRAL CALIFORNIA SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA WINTER TRAVEL ROAD TRIPS GEAR

Leave a Comment